Select, Case in if-else statement requires double inputs

I need to find out where is the problem. I need to write a script that prompts users to make Yes/No choice in if/else statement. In general I have a bash script that runs like this

if CONDITION; then
    COMMANDS1
else
    COMMANDS2
    echo "Does this look okay to you? (WARNING: This action will not be recoverable!) :          
    PS3="Select a number: "
    select yn in "Yes" "No"
    do
          case $yn in
               "Yes" )
                echo "Ok!" ; break ;;
                "No" )
                echo "Aborted!" ; break ;;
          esac
    done
fi

But when I run the script, it shows

Does this look okay to you? (WARNING: This action will not be recoverable!)
1) Yes
2) No
Select a number: (I have to press anything here)
Select a number: (Only this input does something).

I ran the script with sh -vx and it shows that it runs both select and case separately. How do I make sure I only need one input?

+ echo 'Does this look okay to you? (WARNING: This action will not be recoverable!) : '
Does this look okay to you? (WARNING: This action will not be recoverable!) : 
+ PS3='Select a number: '
+ select yn in '"Yes"' '"No"'
1) Yes
2) No
Select a number: 1
+ case "$yn" in
Select a number: 2
+ case "$yn" in
+ echo 'Aborted!'
Aborted!
+ break

Thank you very much!

EDIT: I am running bash on Mac OS 14.1.