Thunar and ls different file size
I have a complete android userdata partition image on disk and it shows 48.9 GiB on Thunar but only 3.8 GB in ls and Baobab. How is it possible ?
Thanks
This might be a sparse file; i.e. a file that has "holes" where there really is nothing, just zeroes. Since you wrote that this was a disk partition, that is actually quite likely.
[sh @ balrog] .../work/test/sparse 24 % ls -lh
total 1.1M
-rw-rw-r-- 1 sh 1000 1001M 5. Feb 2016 sparse-1MB.bin
-rw-rw-r-- 1 sh 1000 8.0K 16. Jun 2020 sparse-8k
-rw-rw-r-- 1 sh 1000 8.0K 16. Jun 2020 sparse-8k-zero
-rw-rw-r-- 1 sh 1000 1000M 5. Feb 2016 sparse-zero.bin
[sh @ balrog] .../work/test/sparse 25 % ls -sh1
total 1.1M
1.0M sparse-1MB.bin
4.0K sparse-8k
0 sparse-8k-zero
0 sparse-zero.bin
Many file tools can’t really handle them correctly. The problem is that those files really have two sizes: The nominal size (which is what ls -l
and Thunar show you) and the true allocated size (which du -h
or ls -sh
show).
Be really careful when copying such a file; some tools may "fill" the holes and actually write zeroes where there used to be the hole, really consuming the nominal size. See also man cp
and the --sparse
option.
If you use that kind of files often, use QDirStat which shows you both sizes at once: